
We strive to provide the most up to date and accurate information regarding growth and development in Tinicum Township and the surrounding area.
Light up the Delaware River Celebration:
To learn more about this celebration and the potential threats
posed by gas drilling in our area visit the following web site:
http://www.lightupthedelawareriver.com/
Carr Tract Update (August 2009):
It came as no surprise that Main Street
Developers were not pleased by the decision of Tinicum's Board of
Supervisors to reject their challenge to Tinicum's ordinance
protecting agricultural soils wherever they occur within the township.
Main Street attorney Robert Gundlach has now filed an appeal of
Tinicum's decision to the Bucks County Court of Common Pleas.
The Board of ECOBucks has deliberated on
whether or not we should continue our involvement in the case as an
Interested Party. In these tough economic times, we had to decide whether
it might be more important to preserve our funds for the eventual defense
of our ordinances relating to Main Street and the Piper Group's other
proposed developments.
Our participation in the many months of
hearings which ended with the decision by the Supervisors certainly had an
effect on the outcome. Mr Gundlach was clearly aware of the
opposition of Tinicum residents to his challenge. He even referred to the
Save Our Water signs posted around the township. And the
Supervisors, in their rejection of the challenge, quoted the testimony of
Thomas L. Daniels, PhD, the expert witness who was presented by ECO Bucks.
Dr Daniels is a Professor of Land Use
Planning at U of Penn, a former Director of the Agricultural Preserve
Board of Lancaster County, PA,, and winner of the 1996 National
Achievement Award from the American Farmland Trust.
Gundlach charged that the Supervisors erred
in granting party status to ECOBucks "because it is composed of members
throughout an entire geographic region, none of which were specifically
identified and no information was provided to Appellant as to the nature
of the alleged affect [sic] of the Cure Challenge on the organization."
The first issue the court is addressing is
whether to grant the developers' request to reopen the record and take
additional evidence. Among the additional evidence they propose is
testimony about stream discharge from sewage treatment plants. After the
issue of admitting additional evidence is resolved by the court, the
parties will file briefs on the substantive legal issues in the case and
we will await a ruling from the Court.
Whichever side loses at the county court
level will have the ability to appeal to the Commonwealth Court, where
another round of legal briefs would need to be filed. It can easily
take a few years for this case to wind its way through the court process.
The ECO Board has considered the impact our
participation in the case might have on any of the elected judges who
would hear the appeals. We have decided that ECOBucks should continue to
retain Attorney Jordan Yeager to represent ECOBucks and to participate in
this case. We cannot let our resolve weaken as our case slowly works its
way through the court system.
Accordingly, Yeager filed a brief on behalf
of ECO on July 29, citing precedents in court cases, provisions of the PA
Municipal Planning Code, and examples of testimony from Gundlach's and
Tinicum's expert witnesses.
Among the points made by Yeager were cases
which established that an ordinance is not to be declared invalid merely
because it may deprive the owner of most lucrative and profitable uses.
So long as it may be reasonably used for purposes permitted under
ordinance, the owner may not legally complain. Another case found that to
establish the confiscatory nature of zoning regulations, applicant must
prove that regulations have rendered the land to have no value or only
distress value. Several other cited cases established the right of
townships to preserve agricultural lands.
The request to inject additional testimony
about stream discharge was opposed by Yeager on the grounds that this was
not part of original challenge to Tinicum's agricultural soils protection
ordinance. The MPC stipulates that an applicant cannot propose
additional challenges on same parcel until the original challenge is
settled.
Yeager pointed out that Tinicum witnesses
Theilacker and Comitta offered unrebutted expert testimony that
preservation of agricultural soils has secondary benefits including
promoting significant groundwater recharge and replenishment of aquifers,
Gundlach's own witnesses admitted that the
land could accommodate 64 units and comply with ordinances, so they can't
claim that there is no reasonable use of the land. Their expert witness
Ken Amey admitted that he hadn't performed a study of Tinicum's growth, or
identified causes for lack of growth. This rebutted Gundlach's assertion
that Tinicum's ordinances are so restrictive as to inhibit growth.
As we await the decision of the court,
ECO-Bucks appreciates your financial and moral support. We hope our
members agree that this will be an appropriate expenditure of your past
financial support, and that you will pledge to continue to support our
efforts.
Hearings on hold:
New Hearings
will begin on Main Street Development and Piper Group challenges to the
following township ordnances:
·
The Prime Farmland and Agricultural Soils Overlay District
·
The Delaware River Wild and Scenic Overlay District
·
The Woodland and Hedgerow Overlay District
·
The Critical Biodiversity Areas Overlay District
·
The Critical Recharge Areas Overlay District
·
The Wetlands and Wetlands Margin Overlay District
·
The Riparian Buffer Overlay District
·
The Tohickon Creek Watershed Overlay District
·
The Steep Slope Conservation District
·
The impervious surface regulation for a performance subdivision in the
VR-Village Residential Zoning District
In addition, The Piper Group has reserved the right to contest the $500
charge for each hearing after the first.
The challenges apply to the following proposals:
1. “Tohickon Village” (aka
“Cooper/Wehrung Tract”):
Main Street Development Group and property owners
Louis and Geraldine Cooper and
the Wehrung Group, propose
192 garden apartment units in 18
buildings, together with a clubhouse and clubhouse amenities, located
on the west side of Route 611 and Tohickon Valley Road, Ottsville, PA.
2. “Tinicum Sewer and Water
Group”: Tinicum Sewer and
Water Group, L.P and property owners
Penrose and Marion Hallowell,
propose to subdivide 30.39 acres into 2 lots with
construction of a wastewater
treatment plant on Lot 1, proposed as 8 acres, located on Route 611,
opposite the Carr property, Ottsville, PA.
Note: Tinicum Sewer and Water Group, L.P is not affiliated in any way with
Tinicum Township.
3. “Tohickon Valley Farm”:
Piper
Group, Inc., and property owners
Charles and Katherine
Sigety and Nero Enterprises, propose
60 units in 5 apartment buildings
on 11.87 acres located on the east side of Route 611 and Tohickon Valley
Road, Ottsville, PA.
.
4. “Durham Village”: Piper
Group, Inc. and property owners
Charles and Katherine Sigety and
Nero Enterprises, propose 56
townhouse and multiplex units on a 20.94 portion of a 34.662 acre
tract located at Tohickon Valley Road, Durham Road, and Headquarters Road,
Ottsville, PA.
Below you will find a quick guide to our site.
Offer your expertise and ideas and energy, provide articles or information to us, or just general feedback via our REQUEST INFORMATION page.
The PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT MAP shows only development proposals which have been submitted for approval to Township authorities.
Our EVENTS calendar lists hearings, planning commission meeting, ECO-Bucks events, and other community events in the area.
ABOUT US gives a brief background of who we are, why our growing group is taking a stand against sprawl - and what is at stake.
Our PHOTO GALLERY is a collection of the beauty (and beast) that can be found in our local area. Submissions are welcome.
We are assembling an extensive resource listing on our LINKS page, related to local development issues, land preservation, natural resources management, and listings to important Township, County, State, and Federal web sites which provide contact information for elected officials.
IN THE PRESS tracks news in publications and provides references and synopses related to local land issues.
|